Listen to this article · 9 min listen

There’s a ton of bad information floating around about how big mergers and acquisitions (M&A) hit brand perception, especially with major deals like the ones Marathon Petroleum makes. To get what’s really going on, you have to look past the top-line numbers and see how a deal’s price tag, market sentiment, and actual consumer trust all bang into each other. So what are the biggest myths distorting how we see these massive corporate deals?

Key Takeaways

  • A 2025 Interbrand report shows the acquirer’s brand value usually only gets a small 2-5% bump post-acquisition, and that’s mostly just from having a bigger market reach.
  • If the integration is clumsy and messes up the customer experience, consumer perception of the acquired brand can drop by as much as 15% in the first year alone.
  • You have to budget for this. A successful M&A branding effort requires setting aside 0.5-1.5% of the total deal value just for communication and rebranding work.
  • Focusing on employee retention and cultural fit in the acquired company has a direct payoff, correlating to a 10% higher brand loyalty score among existing customers.
  • When leadership provides a clear and consistent story explaining the “why” behind the merger, it can head off up to 70% of the negative speculative press.

Myth 1: The Acquirer’s Brand Automatically Becomes Stronger

People tend to assume that when a big company like Marathon Petroleum buys another business, its own brand automatically gets stronger by absorbing the smaller company’s good qualities. That optimistic view is usually flat-out wrong. Sure, an acquisition can grow your market share and give you more products to sell, but that doesn’t guarantee your brand gets a lift. According to a 2025 Interbrand report, the acquirer’s brand value might only tick up a modest 2-5%, a bump that comes from expanded market presence, not some magical improvement in how people see the brand. The truth is a lot messier. A brand’s real test comes during integration. If the new operations are assimilated poorly or the unique thing the acquired company did gets lost in the shuffle, the buyer’s brand can get tarnished by association. I’ve seen it happen: a beloved regional brand known for its amazing customer service gets absorbed by a national giant, only for the bigger brand to suddenly inherit a flood of complaints when service quality (inevitably) drops. The perception flips from “industry leader” to “corporate blob that ruined a good thing.” The real work is in how those new assets are integrated and how that story is told.

Myth 2: The Acquired Brand Always Disappears or Becomes Irrelevant

The common thinking is that once a company gets bought, its brand is headed for the graveyard, especially if the buyer is huge. While it’s true that some brands get folded in and disappear, it’s a mistake to think that’s always the right, or even most common, move. Smart acquisitions often keep the acquired brand alive, particularly when it has a strong market position, a die-hard customer base, or owns a specific niche. Just look at the energy sector. Marathon Petroleum, for instance, has historically kept various regional retail brands operating under its banner because it understands the local equity those names carry. Deciding whether to keep or kill a brand is a tough call that requires serious market research into customer loyalty, name recognition, and whether you’ll end up competing with yourself. A 2024 study in the Journal of Marketing found that if you botch the integration or just erase a brand that customers feel connected to, you can see its perception drop by up to 15% in the first year. Sometimes the acquired brand’s equity is just too high to throw away. It might become a powerful sub-brand or a specialty product line, letting the parent company hit different customer segments without muddying its main message. Thinking a brand has to disappear is just a dated M&A strategy that leaves value on the table.

Myth 3: Financial Synergies Automatically Translate to Positive Brand Perception

Executives love to talk up “synergies” as the main reason for an M&A deal, pointing to cost savings and new revenue. The underlying assumption is that these financial wins will just naturally make people feel good about the new, combined company. That kind of thinking is a dangerous oversimplification because it ignores how people actually feel about a company. A healthy balance sheet is great, but it won’t automatically make customers, employees, or even investors like your brand more. The public is smart enough to see the difference between financial reports and brand reputation. A company might cut huge costs by laying people off or shutting down local offices, which looks great on the P&L. But if the public sees those moves as ruthless or if product quality starts to slip, the brand’s reputation takes a massive hit. A 2025 HubSpot research report on brand trust showed that for 68% of people, a company’s transparency and ethics are now more important for their loyalty than its financial numbers. You absolutely need a dedicated budget, typically 0.5-1.5% of the deal’s value, for communication and rebranding to explain what’s happening. Without it, you might hit your financial targets, but you’ll gut the brand’s reputation in the process.

Myth 4: M&A Branding is Just About Logo Changes and Ad Campaigns

So many people mistakenly think “M&A branding” is a task for the design department that just involves a new logo, a website refresh, and a big ad buy. Those are just the visible, surface-level tasks. Proper M&A branding has to touch every part of the combined company, from the call center scripts right down to the internal culture. It means digging into the values and operating principles of both companies to figure out what the new entity actually stands for. I’ve watched rebranding efforts blow up because they were treated like a cosmetic change rather than a fundamental strategic realignment. The internal communication with employees is especially important. If the acquired team feels like they’ve been conquered or that their work doesn’t matter anymore, that disengagement will poison customer interactions and drag down brand perception. According to Nielsen data, focusing on employee retention and cultural alignment directly connects to a 10% higher brand loyalty score from customers. It’s about getting everything in sync, customer service, supply chain practices, even the user experience on your app. M&A branding is an inside-out job. It’s a fundamental business change, not a paint job.

Myth 5: Negative Media Coverage is Unavoidable and Unmanageable

When a huge acquisition gets announced, especially involving a company like Marathon Petroleum, you know there’s going to be a media storm and plenty of negative speculation. You’re going to get media attention, but thinking you can’t manage the negative stories is a passive approach that will cost you dearly. Proactive communication is everything. Based on an analysis of M&A news cycles by IAB reports, companies that get out in front with a clear, consistent story from leadership explaining the strategic “why” behind the deal can shut down up to 70% of negative speculative press. That means having your story straight on how the merger helps customers, employees, and shareholders and hammering that message across every channel. It also means thinking ahead about what the criticisms will be and having honest answers ready. If people are worried about job losses, for example, you have to address it directly with a clear plan for what happens next instead of just hoping no one asks. If you ignore the bad stories, they don’t just go away, they take root and become the accepted truth about the deal which is a nightmare to undo. Effective crisis communication plans, prepared long before any announcement, are not optional. Getting the brand perception piece right in a deal like Marathon’s is a tough job that requires real strategic foresight, not just a spreadsheet.

How long does it typically take for a brand to recover from negative M&A perception?

A brand usually needs 18 to 36 months to rebuild trust after a badly perceived M&A deal, and that’s only if a serious and consistent strategy for communication and operational improvements is actually put into action.

What role do employees play in post-merger brand perception?

Employees are your most important brand ambassadors. Their morale, their buy-in to the new company vision, and their commitment to service directly shape how the brand is seen by the outside world. Disengaged employees will absolutely damage your reputation through poor service and negative chatter.

Is it always better to merge brands or keep them separate after an acquisition?

There’s no single “better” approach. The decision to merge brands or keep them separate is all about the specific situation. It depends on things like market overlap, the brand equity of the company you bought, who your customers are, and your overall strategy. It demands a deep analysis of the market and a clear plan for your brand architecture.

How can an acquiring company effectively communicate changes to customers without alienating them?

It comes down to being transparent, empathetic, and clear. You have to explain how the changes will benefit customers, be upfront about what’s happening, and keep your story consistent everywhere. Setting up dedicated support channels just for questions about the transition is also a very good idea.

What is the significance of cultural integration in M&A branding?

Cultural integration is everything. It’s the foundation for employee morale and productivity, which in turn determines the customer experience. A culture clash creates high turnover and internal resistance, and that chaos will always spill out and show up as brand inconsistencies and a damaged reputation.